Skip to main contentSkip to footer
Peter & Co. Jewelers logo
  • Sale
  • Diamonds
  • Engagement
    Engagement Rings
    Engagement RingsAnniversary Rings
    Engagement Designers
    Tacori Engagement RingsHearts on Fire Engagement RingsFana Engagement RingsA.Jaffe

    Explore All Engagement
  • Education
    Learn About Your Ring Setting
    Learn About Jewelry Metals

    Explore All Education
  • Wedding Bands
    Wedding Band Builder
    Women's Wedding Bands
    Band BuilderDiamond Wedding BandsGold Wedding Bands
    Men's Wedding Bands
    Alternative Metal Wedding BandsDiamond Wedding BandsGold Wedding BandsPlatinum Wedding Bands

    Explore All Wedding Bands
  • Fine Jewelry
    Gifts Under $500
    Gifts Under $1000
    Rings
    Diamond RingsGold RingsSilver RingsColored Stone RingsPearl Rings
    Earrings
    Diamond EarringsDiamond Stud EarringsLab Grown Diamond Stud EarringsGold EarringsSilver EarringsColored Stone EarringsPearl Earrings
    Necklaces
    Diamond NecklacesGold PendantsSilver NecklacesColored Stone NecklacesPearl Necklaces
    Bracelets
    Diamond BraceletsGold BraceletsSilver BraceletsColored Stone BraceletsPearl Bracelets
    Men's
    Men's RingMen's BraceletsMen's Necklaces

    Explore All Fine Jewelry
  • Children's Jewelry
  • Watches
    Women's Watches
    Men's Watches

    Explore All Watches
  • Gifts & Pens
  • Gift Guides
    • Mother's Day Gift Guide
    • Graduation Gift Guide
    • Father's Day Gift Guide
  • Designers
    • A. Jaffe
    • Ania Haie
    • AVA Couture
    • Ball Watch
    • Bella Grace Jewelry
    • CITIZEN Watches
    • Cross
    • Fana
    • FOPE
    • Hearts On Fire
    • Heather B. Moore
    • John Hardy
    • Jorge Revilla
    • Lashbrook Designs
    • LINQ Permanent Bracelets
    • Melinda Maria
    • Shinola
    • Shy Creation
    • T. Jazelle
    • Tacori
  • Services
    • LINQ Permanent Bracelets
    • Jewelry & Watch Repair
    • Jewelry Insurance
    • Gold & Jewelry Buying
    • Financing
    • Band Builder
    • Custom Design
    • Diamond Upgrade
    • Zillion
  • About
    Who We Are
    About UsIn the CommunityOur HistoryMeet Our StaffAntwerp DiamondsZillion
    News & Events
    Latest NewsSocial MediaStore ReviewsOur Blog
    Contact the Store
    (440) 933-4871Google Directions
    Send us a Message

    Explore All About
  • My AccountToggle My Account Menu
    Login

    Don’t have an account? Sign up now

  • Diamonds
  • Engagement
  • Wedding
  • Jewelry
  • Watches
  • Services
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • Toggle My Account Menu
    Login
    Forgot Password?

    Don’t have an account? Sign up now

  • Toggle Shopping Cart Menu
  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Upgrading Your Diamond Game

Upgrading Your Diamond Game

Published: Feb 22, 2026
Upgrading Your Diamond Game
Author: 
The Team
Your diamond jewelry holds sparkles and memories. However, you may find yourself ready for a change over time. At Peter & Co. Jewelers, we help customers throughout Avon Lake and the surrounding Cleveland, Ohio, area find the perfect way to elevate their diamond jewelry, whether it’s updating a cherished engagement ring, trading in an old piece, or redesigning something timeless into something truly you. Here, we discuss diamond upgrades, what to know, and reasons why people trade in the old for something new. 

Why Upgrade Your Diamond?

There’s no single reason why people choose a diamond upgrade. In fact, there are many reasons why people come to us to look for a new gem, including:

  • Celebrations: An anniversary, promotion, or life change is the perfect opportunity to enhance your jewelry to match how far you’ve come.
  • Evolving style: Tastes change. Now you might prefer a different cut, setting, or size than when you first bought your ring.
  • Improved quality: Over time, many couples choose to upgrade to a diamond with higher brilliance or a different quality balance that better reflects their current taste and lifestyle.
  • Sentimentality: Some customers want to preserve the emotion of their original ring while refreshing the design with a new center diamond or updated setting.
An upgrade is about building on memories, not replacing them. When you trade in your stone for a new one, you create a solid foundation for future moments.

Diamond Upgrade Options

At Peter & Co. Jewelers, we believe every diamond tells a story, and your next one should reflect yours. No matter why you’re looking for an upgrade, you have a few options, including:

Replacing the Center Stone

This is the most popular choice for engagement rings. If the ring design allows for it, you can keep your original band and setting or select a new design that highlights your upgraded diamond. Many customers choose a larger carat size, but others focus on improving cut, clarity, or color for more brilliance and shine.

Redesigning the Setting

Sometimes a new setting makes an old stone look brand new. For instance, switching from a traditional solitaire to a halo can make your diamond appear larger. We offer both classic and custom settings in 14K and 18K white gold, rose gold, yellow gold, and platinum. This variety allows you to create something truly one-of-a-kind.

Adding Accent Diamonds

Enhance your ring’s sparkle by adding side stones or upgrading to a three-stone design that symbolizes your past, present, and future. This subtle change can dramatically refresh your jewelry’s appearance without replacing your main diamond. 

Trading In and Up

Peter & Co. Jewelers offers diamond trade-in services, allowing you to apply the value of your current diamond toward a new purchase, such as a necklace or earrings. Our jewelry buyers will assess your piece and guide you through options for trading up to a new piece or a higher-quality stone.

Key Considerations Before You Upgrade

Before committing to a diamond upgrade, it’s important to consider a few factors, including:

  • Budget and value: Set a comfortable range before you begin. We can help you find the best stone for you, whether you want a larger size, better clarity, or a new setting.
  • Certification: Look for a diamond evaluated by a respected grading authority such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) or American Gem Society (AGS). This ensures your stone is authentic and is accurately graded for quality and value.
  • Lifestyle: Consider your daily activities. Some customers prefer a low-profile setting for active lifestyles, while others love the height and presence of a raised design.
Upgrading a diamond is a significant decision, which is why you should collaborate with a jeweler who understands both craftsmanship and sentiment. At Peter & Co. Jewelers, our family-owned jewelry store has been in business since 1987, providing expert diamond knowledge and personal service you can trust.

Elevate Your Sparkle with Peter & Co. Jewelers

Whether you’re celebrating a milestone, starting a new chapter, or are simply ready for something that better reflects you, upgrading your diamond jewelry at Peter & Co. Jewelers is a wonderful way to honor your journey. Contact us today to schedule a diamond upgrade consultation with one of our specialists in Avon Lake, OH.
Categories
Education4Jewelry10Holidays2
  • Previous Article
  • Next Article
Peter & Co. Jewelers
32020 Walker Rd
Avon Lake, OH 44012
(440) 933-4871
Store Information
Hours
Mon-Fri:Monday - Friday:
10:00am - 6:00pm
Saturday:
10:00am - 4:00pm
Sunday:
Closed
Designers
  • A. Jaffe
  • ANIA HAIE
  • Ava Couture
  • BALL WATCH
  • BELLA GRACE JEWELRY
  • CITIZEN
  • CROSS
  • FANA
  • FOPE
  • FREDERIC SAGE
  • HEARTS ON FIRE
  • VIEW ALL DESIGNERS
Jewelry
  • Engagement
  • Women's Wedding Bands
  • Men's Wedding Bands
  • Rings
  • Earrings
  • Necklaces
  • Bracelets
  • Chains
  • Watches
  • Men's
  • Children's Jewelry
  • Personalized Jewelry
  • Giftware & Pens
Our Store
  • About Us
  • Our Blog
  • Store Services
  • Store Policies
  • Privacy Policy
  • My Account
  • Sitemap
STAY CONNECTED

Enter your email below to sign up for our newsletter

  • Visit the authorizenet website
  • Affirm Financing
  • Visit the ags website
  • Visit the bbb-accredited website
  • Visit the gia website
  • Visit the ijo website
  • Visit the joa website
  • Return Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility Statement

© 2026 Peter & Co. Jewelers. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by: Punchmark

Loading

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.